If you’re considering living in Lancaster, you’re probably wondering, what makes locals love this city? Located in the heart of Pennsylvania’s Amish country, Lancaster offers a blend of historic charm and modern conveniences.
Before making a move, it’s important to weigh the pros and cons of living in Lancaster so you can make an informed decision.
Lancaster at a glance
Walk Score: 81 | Bike Score: 58
Median Sale Price: $275,000 | Average Rent for 1-Bedroom Apartment: $1,659
Houses for rent in Lancaster | Apartments for rent in Lancaster | Homes for sale in Lancaster
1. Pro: Affordable cost of living
Lancaster’s cost of living is lower than many cities in Pennsylvania, making it appealing to budget-conscious residents. Rent and groceries are reasonably priced compared to larger cities.
2. Con: Limited public transportation
Public transportation in Lancaster is limited. The bus system, while useful, doesn’t cover all areas comprehensively. If you live outside the city center, having a car becomes necessary to navigate daily life.
3. Pro: Scenic outdoor spaces
Living in Lancaster gives you access to stunning countryside and well-maintained parks. The nearby Susquehanna River is a great spot for hiking, fishing, and boating. Parks like Long’s Park provide free summer concerts and spacious picnic areas, giving residents ample space for outdoor activities.
4. Con: Quiet nightlife
Nightlife for people in Lancaster doesn’t doesn’t quite reach the level of those living in Pittsburgh or Philadelphia. If you prefer a real lively nightlife, the city may feel a bit slow after dark. Though there are local bars and restaurants, most establishments close early.
5. Pro: Historic charm
Lancaster is steeped in history, with well-preserved brick buildings dating back to the 18th century. Living in Lancaster allows you to enjoy the charm of cobblestone streets and historic homes. Places like Central Market, one of the oldest continuously operating farmers markets in the country, highlight the city’s fascinating past.
6. Con: Limited job market
While Lancaster has a growing economy, the job market remains limited in certain industries. Major employers include healthcare and manufacturing, but those in tech or finance may struggle to find as many opportunities. This can make it difficult for specialized professionals to find the right fit.
7. Pro: Thriving local food scene
Lancaster is known for its fresh, locally sourced food, with plenty of farm-to-table dining options. The Central Market features fresh produce, meats, and homemade goods directly from local farmers. Beyond that, tons of restaurants incorporate seasonal ingredients, giving foodies a variety of tastes to experience.
8. Con: Traffic during tourist season
Lancaster attracts a good amount of tourists, particularly to its Amish attractions. During peak tourist season, especially in the summer and fall, traffic can become a headache. Roads near popular sites, like The Amish Farm and House and Central Market, can be congested, slowing down your daily commute.
9. Pro: Family-friendly
Families find Lancaster a great place to raise kids due to its excellent schools. The city offers plenty of family-friendly events, including festivals and fairs, and attractions like the Lancaster Science Factory.
10. Con: Winter weather
Living in Pennsylvania means enduring cold and snowy winters. Snowstorms can disrupt daily life, especially for those unaccustomed to harsh winters. Clearing snow and navigating icy roads may become challenging, and the cold can linger into early spring.
11. Pro: Access to major cities
Though Lancaster exudes a small-town feel, it’s conveniently located near some of the largest cities in Pennsylvania. Friends living in Philadelphia are about an hour and a half away, making weekend trips easy. You can also reach Baltimore or Washington, D.C. within a few hours, providing access to more urban amenities without living in a crowded city.
12. Con: Lacking entertainment options
Entertainment options in Lancaster are somewhat lackluster when compared to larger cities. While there are theaters, museums, and galleries, choices for more niche entertainment may not be as abundant.
13. Pro: Strong sense of community
One of the best parts of living in Lancaster is the strong sense of community. Many residents have lived here for generations, fostering a welcoming, close-knit atmosphere. From local events to neighborhood gatherings, Lancaster residents often form tight connections with their neighbors.
A native of the northern suburbs of Chicago, Carson made his way to the South to attend Wofford College where he received his BA in English. After working as a copywriter for a couple of boutique marketing agencies in South Carolina, he made the move to Atlanta and quickly joined the Rent. team as a content marketing coordinator. When he’s off the clock, you can find Carson reading in a park, hunting down a great cup of coffee or hanging out with his dogs.
